The Chinese
Educational System
I am most definitely
not going to be happy to leave in 6 months (life here is too fascinating), but
Z misses American school a lot. Now that he is on school vacation
(until Feb 24), he is OK and happy, but school is BRUTAL (draconian education
style; teachers hit the kids on the head and face for not doing the work up to
standards and children are publicly shamed regularly). When asked, Z describes
school as “torture.”
His teacher is nice to
him because he is the only non-Chinese student in the school, but he has to
witness all the other stuff in the classroom and it bothers him a great deal.
Not only that, but having to sit for hours on end without moving is impossible
for him. All the other foreign parents I know send their children to private
international schools. The companies they work for pay the fees. The fees for
those schools are out of my reach financially. Home schooling? Both Z and I
would lose our minds. He needs lots of interaction with other people on any given
day. Because he is attending public school where no one speaks English (outside
of simple sentences in English class) Z is learning Mandarin
in leaps and bounds; children who attend international schools do not speak
more than a very little bit of Chinese. Mostly, the experience of attending
public school in China is giving him a wild ride on the Chinese Public
Education Train. All aboard!
While relaxing on the
beach in Sanya, Z and I were talking about the differences between the American
Educational System and the Chinese Educational System and making a list. The
contrast is sharp and shocking. I was always skeptical when I heard people like
Arne Duncan (Secretary of Education under Obama) chastise Americans by saying,
"Chinese children are out-scoring American children in math by 80
percent." Now I have even more reason to feel indignant about that unfair
comparison. These children memorize math equations and facts until they can do
them at lightning speed, but that is all they can do. They memorize, memorize,
memorize. But ask them to think critically or solve
an analytic problem and they are like turtles on their backs. Do we
want a population of children and then adults like that? Sure, they
"outscore" American children on bubble exams of math problems because
our educational system doesn't depend on "drilling, drilling,
drilling." I told an American friend who is an educator that third graders
in China can do triple digit multiplication in their heads. She said, “They
must have an algorithm, a mnemonic, some sort of math “game” that helps
them." Nope. Just lightning-fast memorization of their times tables.
Because of Z's
experience, I am even more certain that what they are doing is not only wrong,
but bad for children. We can't hold up Chinese children's math skills as a
model of success. It is only a model of bad educational practices and horrible
treatment of children. The children here do nothing but study/memorize.
As John Henry Newman
believed when designing the Liberal Arts system that is now part and parcel of
the U.S.A.’s university system, you can’t have a strong Republic unless you
have a widely educated populous. The people not only need to be educated in a
broad range of topics, but they need to be able to think critically and
analyze. The Chinese Educational System educates in the other direction. Rote
memorization of facts. Recitation. Don’t think, just memorize. Don’t ask “why?”
It isn’t for you to know “why?” Homework each night is dominated by hours of
math problems (the same math problems over and over again) and memorizing
Chinese myths, parables, fables, and Confucian texts. These all must be recited
word-for-word the next day in class. If you can't recite perfectly, well, the
day will not go well for you.
At the university
level, education is seen as job training, focused exclusively on skills needed
for employment. Each university in China focuses on a field. Only classes
related directly to that field are taught at that university. Xidian is a
“telecommunications university” (in Xi’an there are 52 universities ranging
from the Welding University to the Railroad University to the Petrochemical
University to the Medical University). At Xidian, there are only classes
offered that relate to telecommunications. Don’t expect to see an art, music,
psychology, literature, sociology, or even a chemistry class at the university.
What we in the United States take for granted as part of a university education
(all those “general education requirements” that make us well-rounded and open
up our minds to different ideas and perspectives) are simply not part of
universities here. There are art classes at the “Fine Arts University,” but at
none of the other 51 universities in Xi’an. I haven’t heard of a “Sociology
University” or a “Psychology University,” so classes for those subjects may not
be taught in this city of 6 million people at all.
You get the idea.
I see the results of
this narrowly focused educational approach that hinges on rote learning and
job-training skills in my college students. Very, very few of them can think
critically or analyze. They can memorize and summarize with amazing speed. But
ask their opinion on something? Nope. Most can't do it. And they really can't
imagine that there is more than one answer to a question. I have had students
say to me, in exasperation, “Just tell us the answer!” I
patiently respond, “There is not one answer, but many. What do you
think?” A few weeks ago one of my frustrated students said, “It doesn’t
matter what I think. I need to know the answer. It is your job to tell us the
answers.” It is so very, very sad. They are college students, but their
critical thinking and analytical skills are about those of a 3rd grader in the
states.
Yes, a third grader in
China can do triple digit multiplication in their head (quick! What’s 314 x
233? Too late. A Chinese child has already provided the answer). Yes, they can
blow through pages of problems in minutes, leaving Z in the dust, barely
finishing the first ten problems on his four-page exam. The Chinese children can
do that because they memorize for hours at a time during the day and again when
they get home at night. They do equations over and over and over again. You
would not believe the redundancy of the homework. It has been the same homework
for months, just different numbers. The monotony should kill them, but it
doesn’t. That memorization part of their brain is the size of Arnold
Schwarzenegger’s 1980s era biceps.
Even over the New
Year’s holiday, Chinese school children do not get a break. Z’s teacher sent
home two workbooks with each student that were to be completed by the end of
the break. I thought, “Oh, finally! Maybe now they are moving on to something new.”
Nope. The same stuff. The same stuff they have been studying
for the past four months. Just more of it. Keep doing it. Faster. Faster.
Faster. Do it until you don’t even have to think. It is not
accelerated math. It is not different math. This math is not anything different
from what third graders in the U.S. are studying. What is different
is that third graders in the U.S. are also learning other things,
too. In the U.S. teachers teach a concept, they make sure the students know
it, and then they move on. To other things. Like problem solving,
as in “Here is a situation. How would you resolve it? What are some possible/probable solutions?”
Critical thinking sorts of things. Analytical tasks. Open-ended questioning.
For a communist
government, the “don’t think, just memorize” approach to education is
essential. The last thing you want to create is a billion or so people who are
practiced at asking “why? Or “how?” and expecting some answers – or worse yet –
a population of people who are capable of arriving at various answers, all
equally plausible.
Recently the
government had an "expert" on t.v. during the 7-8 p.m. hour of “news”
(every channel in China plays the same “news” at 7 p.m. – your remote is not
broken; it is the same news on every channel, issued by the government). This
“expert” said that the biggest contributor to China’s air pollution problem was
cooking oil. That's right! Not cars, not factories, but cooking. And people
believed it. I had a college professor say to me, "It's true. I heard the
expert say it." Why does the government tell them the pollution problem is
cooking oil? Because then the people are responsible for the pollution, not the
government. Why do people believe that ridiculous answer? Because even
highly-educated folks have not been taught to think critically and
analytically. There is one answer. Someone will tell you what it is.
It has been good for Z
to experience the major differences between these educational systems, but we
are both glad it is just for a year. The mind-numbing redundancy and rigidity
of the school work makes him hate school. He now waxes nostalgic about his
school days in St. Joseph, Missouri. In China there is no such thing as
positive reinforcement (that is seen as coddling). Negative reinforcement to
correct errant behavior is the only model these teachers know, it
seems. But I’ll let Z tell you about what he has noted as the differences
between his primary school experience here in China v. the United States.
Z’s blog 1
Hello. This is not a
blog written by Kay. This is Z’s first blogpost on the educational system of
China, and boy, do I have a lot to say. There is going to be two solid pages of
freakin’ rant about Chinese school coming up right after these previews of the
new movie: “The sound of Zhongwen*”.
I speak legend Chinese
in America. But in CHINA? I’m not so good. Okay, I admit, I am a little more
fluent than mom (she would say a LOT more fluent), but that doesn’t matter when
I’m speaking to a Chinese person (99% of my days out). Here is an example
conversation between me and some guy named Yu Bingshan.
YU: Ni jiao shen-me
ming-zi?
ME: Wo jiao Zeph.
YU: Ni de xiao-xue zai
nail-ah?
ME: Wo zai xi-dian
xiao-xue.
YU: Ni shi na-li guo
jia de?
ME: Wo shi mei-guo
ren.
YU: Blah blah blah de
blah?
ME: Duibuqi, wo bu
dong-le.
Einglish translation:
I told him my name, school, and country, but past that it could be anything.
Mei-yo le.
Coming soon to a
Wordpress near you.
*Zhongwen = Chinese
language
The main event
Ladies and gentlemen,
boys and girls, let’s get ready to… Ramble! On and on about the differences
between education in China and America. *Funky techno blare “Du du du rere rere
du du…”*
CHINA
|
UNITED STATES
|
Concrete, bare walls
|
Walls decorated with all sorts of cool posters, paintings, and
educational information
|
Rows of Desks
|
Desks arranged as the teacher or class wants; rarely in rows
|
Nothing but blandness in general
|
Color, texture, and lots to look at
|
Uniforms and scarves to honor Chairman Mao (who is
over-honored, in my opinion)
|
Dress code = no belly shirts, no caps, no flip-flops or shoes
with wheels (other than that, you are good to go)
|
Weekly hand/nail hygiene checks at the school gate (if you are
dirty, your name is written on the blackboard inside the gate to shame you)
|
Be as dirty as you wanna be, as long as you don’t have head
lice
|
Organized Tai Chi every morning and every afternoon in the
courtyard (twice a day for 20 minutes each)
|
No group activities or exercise outside of P.E. class
|
National Anthem (if you move, you are punished by having to
stand for 30 minutes outside your classroom without moving at the end of the
school day)
|
Pledge of Allegiance, but no big deal if you don’t want
to say it
|
Rote memorization and recitation for four hours in the morning
and three hours in the afternoon (if you slip up in your recitation – no
books allowed – the class chants the correct words and you have to begin
again from the beginning of the passage)
|
Critical thinking and analysis is emphasized. No memorization
or recitation, but lots of reading and reading aloud
|
Ten minute potty/classroom cleaning/recess breaks every 50
minutes
|
Recess once a day for 30 minutes; bathroom breaks as needed,
you just get up and go (as long as the teacher approves)
|
The teacher has the right to hit students with her book, their
books, or her hand if they do not do their homework, are late, or mess up in
class, or if the teacher is just in a bad mood
|
No hitting students. Ever. Teachers are really nice to
students and use positive reinforcement 99.99% of the time
|
The teacher will rip up a student’s homework if the work is
not satisfactory
|
Teacher will put red ink on the homework if it is not
satisfactory
|
Students often cry in class
|
Students are often smiling and talking in class
|
Teachers will shame a student by shaming his/her parents
|
Teacher will talk privately with a student at the teacher’s
desk
|
Everyone must leave the school for lunch; students whose
parents work must go home with women who will fix them lunch (called “lunch
tables”); after lunch, everyone must take a nap
|
Everyone has lunch at school and sometimes parents and
grandparents come to have lunch, too; no sleeping at school
|
Eye and head self-massage twice a day (morning and
afternoon); double when you have art class
|
Bullies make you want to slam your head on the slide during
recess (other than that, no head pain)
|
Chinese students are taught to obey and never ask “why?”; it
is like “why?” is the teacher’s fire-breathing cue
|
Teachers are constantly asking students “why?” and
students have full permission to ask the teacher “why?”
|
Students clean the classrooms and they do this during the
ten-minute breaks; they have mops, brooms, and little watering cans to
sprinkle water on the floor
|
We have janitors
|
No books in the classroom (other than the students’ text
books)
|
Comfortable reading areas with shelves of books in every
classroom, waiting to be cracked open and . . . (sorry! I am a book
enthusiast)
|
No school library
|
Lots of great books in the school library/media center
|
No school gymnasium
|
Of course there is a gym. It is used for P.E., school programs
(none in China!), and band and chorus practice
|
No parents are allowed (ever!); even when there was a
school-wide Tai Chi competition, no parents were allowed to watch. Parents
had to stand outside the gate and crane to see even a bit of the competition
|
Parents are encouraged to come to lunch and to volunteer at
the school; parent participation is a big part of school life (I love it when
my mom comes and brings Jimmy John’s for lunch)
|
The only time parents are invited to school is if a student is
in BIG trouble; it is never, ever good (no such thing as “parent/teacher
conference”) – my mom had to go talk to the teacher once. Don’t ask.
|
Parents are invited to various programs and events at the
school throughout the year; I am happy to see my mom at my school
|
There are 50-55 students per classroom; 7-8 classes per grade;
2,500 students in the school
|
Classes have about 20 students in them and if there are more
students, a teacher must have a “para-educator” to help
|
Chinese is taught for at least two hours every day; Ditto for
math (and only rote memorization)
|
There is never two-hours of one subject
|
Science is boring; it is lecture (no fun experiments or group
activities)
|
Science is fun as fun can be; we do lots and lots and lots of
experiments. If not, we are watching an educational video
|
Students must sit in their seat at all times
|
Students do sit, but they also move around a lot
|
No school band or sports teams
|
Duh.
|
No theater or plays
|
Reader’s theater is one of the fun things about school
|
No field trips
|
Field trips every fall and spring to really interesting or
exciting places; all heck breaks loose on field trip days
|
Hour of “mandatory” study time after school; everyone gets out
of school at 5:30 p.m.
|
School ends at 3:10
|
No decorations on classroom walls (sometimes the teacher draws
a picture with colored chalk on the board)
|
Student art and work is put on the walls
|
No encouragement for reading independently; only a chart to
indicate “good behavior”
|
Charts and competitions to encourage reading, e.g. Reading
Counts Quizzes
|
No “free time” or “D.E.A.R.” time (Drop Everything And Read)
|
Daily D.E.A.R. time and other times that we can read what we
want
|
No fundraisers or philanthropies
|
Too many fundraisers and philanthropies; at least once a month
or more
|
Weekly exams in math and Chinese that determine class rank
(and students sit according to class rank) – applies to grades 4-6 only
|
Quarterly exams, not including the M.A.P. exam at the end of
the year
|
No films in class
|
Educational films in class and we get to watch fun movies when
it is too cold or wet to go outside for recess
|
Sometimes students have to stay inside during the 10-minute
breaks because the pollution is too dangerous outside
|
Students sometimes have to stay inside because it is too
cold/wet to go outside for recess
|
Students stand up to answer a question when the teacher calls
on him/her
|
Students raise their hands, but sometimes just blurt out the
answer to questions (because the questions are so easy and the students can’t
control themselves)
|
Every day the students greet the teacher by standing when she
enters the room and saying, in unison, “Laoshi, nin hao?” (Teacher, how are
you?) The teacher responds by saying, “Hen hao. Qing zou.” (Very good. Please
sit.) The students respond: “Xie Xie, Laoshi.” (Thank you, Teacher.)
|
The students don’t greet the teacher or the teacher is in
class when the students arrive
|
When leaving school at lunch and the end of the day, students
line up in rows and march outside. Before they are “dismissed” they must chant
a short military chant with corresponding actions: “Rest! Back to Attention!
Put your arms in front of you, crossed! Put them back to your side! Check
your line! You are dismissed.”
|
Students line up in rows to leave the classroom every day, but
then immediately run down the stairs, trip and fall, and create a bowling
school of doom
|
Absolutely never, never, never interrupt the teacher; if you
need to go to the bathroom, tough
|
You can raise your hand and ask the teacher a question and
most times she won’t be mad, she will actually call on you and answer your
question
|
No such thing as a “school bus”
|
The school buses pick us up near our house and take us to
school if we live too far to walk
|
3-4 hours of homework every night and it is always the same:
doing problems in the textbooks and memorizing passages to recite the next
day
|
Homework is typically different each day and sometimes there
isn’t any work that needs to be done after school
|
No “group projects” or creative lessons or assignments
|
Why do you think I like school in the United States so much?
It’s FUN!
|
The same teacher for six freakin’ years (and the same students
in each grade; nothing changes)
|
New teacher each year and new students every year
|
Students buy their textbooks and keep them at home, lugging
them to school every day
|
Textbooks are kept at school and belong to the school
|
No “special education” help or “language learning” help
|
There are programs that help out kids who need it so they can
stay in school and get the same education as everyone else
|
English is a main subject in school
|
Chinese is not a subject in school
|
Z has 60 days left of
school between now and summer vacation. What he does enjoy are the friends he
has made in school. He misses them now that he hasn’t seen them for a couple
months. Other than that, “I can’t think of anything I like about school.” He only
has one year of this experience. 60 more days. The saddest part: the Chinese
children have a lifetime of it.